Proposing rather than recommending

We do not formally recommend contractors, as an Architect cannot control a contractor’s approach, which may vary from one project to the next. What we can assess is track record: the quality of completed work and conduct on previous projects. We always tender to a balanced list of contractors known to us, any the client would like to include, and capable firms local to the project. A broad list encourages fair pricing and gives genuine choice.

No selection process is infallible, which is why a proper building contract, a detailed schedule of works and contract administration matter. The contract is in place to manage any issues that arise, whichever contractor is appointed.

What to look for

  • Quality of workmanship. Judge how well previous projects have been built rather than whether their style appeals; a contractor’s completed work generally reflects their clients’ tastes.
  • Familiarity with standard contracts. They should be comfortable working under the JCT forms of building contract.
  • Professional conduct. Attentiveness, responsiveness and clear communication, with courtesy towards you, your home and your neighbours.
  • Insurance and references. Ask for evidence of public liability and contract works insurance, and speak to previous clients or visit a completed project.

When tenders are returned, we analyse them line by line against our schedule of works. We query low prices as carefully as high ones, and resolve grouped or unclear pricing before a contractor is appointed. Any advance payment should be clearly justified and supported by a pro forma invoice, for example for an item with a long lead time.

Can you stay at home during the works?

Often, yes, and many of our clients do, principally to avoid the cost of alternative accommodation. It depends on the extent and duration of the works, the household, and above all the kitchen: where a temporary kitchen can be set up elsewhere in the house, remaining in occupation is usually workable.

The works area is sealed off, but some dust and noise should be expected. Staying may add a week or two to the programme as the contractor relocates temporary arrangements; set against the cost of renting, it is usually worthwhile.

When living on site, it is natural to talk with the contractor day to day. Care is needed when a change is agreed informally and carried out on the spot, as it may conflict with the drawings or carry a cost. Any proposed change should be raised with the Architect as well as the contractor, so that it is designed, priced, agreed and recorded before it is built.

How changes are controlled

Some change occurs on every project. Unforeseen site conditions, such as existing construction that differs from what was assumed or variable ground, are covered by the contingency, and early investigations reduce these risks considerably. Changes requested by the client are additions to the project, and the contract sum increases accordingly.

Under the JCT Minor Works Building Contract, which we commonly use, changes are instructed by the contract administrator, and the contract encourages the parties to agree a price before the work proceeds. We make that our standard practice: the cost of any change is agreed and confirmed in writing before it is carried out. Each change is valued as a variation, and work no longer required is credited as an omission. The aim is a final account that contains nothing unexpected.

Protections within the contract

  • Retention. A percentage of each payment, 5% by default under the Minor Works contract, is held back. Half is released at practical completion and the remainder once any defects have been made good.
  • Certified payments. The contractor is paid in stages for work properly completed, as valued and certified by the contract administrator.
  • Insurance. The contract sets out who insures the new work and the existing house. Homeowners should inform their home insurer before work begins.
  • Completion certificate. Building Control issues a completion certificate once the work has been inspected. It should be kept safely, as it will be needed when the property is sold.

We keep client changes to a minimum by allowing sufficient time for design and showing clients exactly what they are commissioning, through drawings, 3D models and, where wanted, virtual reality. A change of mind is far less costly on screen than on site.


To discuss tendering or contract administration for your project, get in touch.